• Personalized baseball Tooth Fairy pillow with navy pinstripe uniform, cap and front pocket for a lost tooth.
  • Hand-held view of the baseball Tooth Fairy pillow showing its smiling embroidered face and navy cap.
  • Back of the baseball Tooth Fairy pillow with a white pocket embroidered “Carmine’s tooth” in navy thread.
  • Handmade baseball Tooth Fairy pillow displayed with a glove, ball and sports-themed nursery decor.
  • Personalized tooth-shaped baseball pillow with navy pinstripes and a front pocket for a Tooth Fairy reward.
  • Close-up of the soft plush baseball Tooth Fairy pillow held against a neutral knitted background.
  • Close-up of the personalized back pocket embroidered “Carmine’s tooth” on the white plush pillow.
  • Video showing the handmade baseball Tooth Fairy pillow from different angles and its personalized pockets.
  • Baseball-inspired Tooth Fairy pillow with an embroidered face, navy cap and pinstripe uniform on a wooden surface.
  • Handmade plush tooth pillow held in one hand, showing the front pocket, navy cap and embroidered baseball details.
  • Soft baseball Tooth Fairy pillow held in both hands to show its 27 cm size and plush texture.
  • Personalized baseball Tooth Fairy keepsake pillow displayed on a neutral surface with its smiling embroidered face.
  • Back of a personalized baseball Tooth Fairy pillow with “Carmines Milchzahn” embroidered on the pocket, displayed with a glove and baseball.
1 13

My Sunny Bunny

Personalized Baseball Tooth Fairy Pillow – Custom Name Keepsake

Personalized Baseball Tooth Fairy Pillow – Custom Name Keepsake

$54.00 USD
$77.00 USD $54.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

This personalized baseball Tooth Fairy pillow is a handmade keepsake for children who love sports. Its tooth-shaped design features a navy pinstripe uniform, embroidered baseball details, a front tooth pocket and a separate back pocket personalized with your child’s name.

Two Tooth Fairy Pockets

  • Front pocket: holds the child’s lost tooth and the Tooth Fairy’s coin, note or small surprise
  • Personalized back pocket: machine embroidered with the child’s name and selected Tooth Fairy wording

Personalization

  • Enter the child’s name exactly as you want it embroidered.
  • Choose English (“[Name]’s tooth”) or German (“[Name]’s Milchzahn”) in the personalization fields.
  • For another language, contact us before ordering to confirm that the wording will fit the pocket.
  • Check the spelling carefully before adding the pillow to your cart.

Product Details

  • Approximate height: 27 cm (10.6 in)
  • Materials: soft OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 certified plush, cotton, satin ribbon, embroidery thread and polyester filling
  • Design: navy-and-white baseball uniform with machine-embroidered face and decorative details
  • Construction: no plastic eyes, buttons or attached small decorative pieces
  • Production time: handmade to order in 1–3 business days
  • Personalized Tooth Fairy letter included: prepared with your child’s name at no additional cost
  • Coin not included: coins, cash, baseball equipment and other items shown in photographs are display props

How the Tooth Fairy Pillow Works

Place the lost tooth inside the pocket on the front. During the visit, the Tooth Fairy can remove the tooth and leave a coin or another small surprise in the same pocket. The personalized pocket on the back displays the child’s embroidered name and selected wording.

A Baseball Gift for a Special Milestone

This custom name tooth pillow combines a first-lost-tooth tradition with a baseball-inspired design. After the Tooth Fairy visit, it can remain a personalized childhood keepsake or sports-themed room decoration.

Care Instructions

Gently hand wash in cool water and allow to air dry. Do not tumble dry.

Safety note: This item is intended as a decorative keepsake and for supervised play. Keep pillows and soft toys out of an infant’s sleep space.

Explore more personalized Tooth Fairy pillows and handmade heirloom gifts from My Sunny Bunny.

For U.S. orders, applicable customs duties and import fees are prepaid by My Sunny Bunny. No additional import charges are due upon delivery. Any sales tax required by law is calculated at checkout.

View full details