• Toy tooth with a New York Yankees cap held by hands on a textured surface
  • Handmade baseball themed tooth fairy pillow shaped like a smiling tooth character wearing a blue cap and Yankees inspired pinstripe uniform with a dollar bill in its pocket.
  • The back side of a personalized baseball tooth fairy pillow featuring custom computer embroidery that reads Carmine's tooth on a soft white plush background.
  • Plush tooth with New York Yankees cap on a wooden crate with sports-themed decor.
  • Toy tooth with New York Yankees uniform on a wooden bench with baseball-themed decor.
  • Toy tooth with a New York Yankees cap held against a knitted beige background
  • Tooth-shaped pillow with 'Carmine's tooth' text on a textured surface
  • Toy tooth with a face, blue cap, and striped uniform held by a hand against a white background
  • Plush tooth-shaped toy with New York Yankees logo held by hands against a gray background
  • Plush tooth-shaped pillow with cartoon face and New York Yankees logo on a beige surface
1 12

My Sunny Bunny

Personalized Baseball Tooth Fairy Pillow – Custom New York Yankees Inspired Stuffed Tooth Toy, Keepsake Gift for Kids

Personalized Baseball Tooth Fairy Pillow – Custom New York Yankees Inspired Stuffed Tooth Toy, Keepsake Gift for Kids

€65,00 EUR
€65,00 EUR
Sale Sold out
Taxes included. Shipping calculated at checkout.

Celebrate a Magical Milestone with a Custom Baseball Twist!

Losing a baby tooth is a major milestone in every child's life. Make the Tooth Fairy's visit unforgettable with this Handmade Personalized Baseball Tooth Fairy Pillow. Inspired by the classic New York Yankees pinstripes and iconic team colors, this unique plush tooth toy is the ultimate gift for young baseball fans, whether they are boys or girls!

The Ultimate Keepsake for Every Special Occasion

This charming handmade pillow is the perfect gift for a baby shower, a newborn celebration, a first birthday, or simply when you want to make a sweet, unexpected surprise for your little one. It is an especially thoughtful and ideal choice if you are searching for a unique gift for a child's first lost baby tooth. This cute, custom pillow is not just a toy—it is designed to be cherished and kept as a precious family heirloom and memory for many long years to come.

Why Parents Love Our Tooth Fairy Pillow:

  • 100% Unique Handmade Craftsmanship: From the initial creative sketch to the final stitch, every single pillow is designed and crafted by me. When you purchase this, you are supporting an independent artisan and getting a truly one-of-a-kind keepsake.
  • Premium Machine Embroidery: No cheap prints or iron-ons here. The friendly tooth face, the cute baseball cap, and the sports uniform features are intricately detailed with high-quality machine embroidery built to last.
  • Custom Name Personalization: Turn this toy into a cherished family heirloom. The back of the pillow features a dedicated soft pocket with your child's name beautifully embroidered on it (for example, "Carmine's tooth").
  • Functional Tooth & Cash Pocket: The front pocket is perfectly sized to hold a lost tooth and securely store a dollar bill reward from the Tooth Fairy, while the personalized back pocket adds an extra layer of magic.

Product Specifications & Details:

  • Design: Unisex styling (perfect for both boys and girls who love baseball).
  • Front Elements: Embroidered cartoon tooth wearing a baseball cap with a pocket.
  • Back Elements: Personalized name embroidery on a secure tooth-collecting pocket.
  • Origin: Proudly 100% handmade.

Looking for more unique, handmade treasures? Every piece in our shop is crafted with the same love, care, and attention to detail. Explore our full collection here to find more personalized keepsakes and vintage-inspired nursery decor for your little one!

View full details